We Asked Designers If Open Concept Floor Plans Are Really Out

Design trends are constantly floating in and out of fashion. From social media fixations to movie mania (like Barbie) and global events (like the pandemic), there are plenty of very real reasons that we start to see more pink or cottagecore aesthetics in interiors.

One of the more surprising trends to emerge? A shift away from open concept layouts in favor of separate rooms. But is this trend just a fleeting idea, or is it here to last?

We tapped designers for their take on whether open concept floor plans are really out—not just in kitchens, but throughout the home.

Designers agree that while open concept floors plans aren't being fully being replaced, there is an increased demand for closed-concept homes with well-defined spaces.

"During the pandemic, so many people transitioned to working and learning from home and needing individualized spaces," says interior designer Emily LaMarque. "As a result, homes with versatile spaces that provide privacy and opportunities for quiet became increasingly desirable, and that need really hasn’t decreased."

However, LaMarque notes that there's still a desire for open-concept great rooms and indoor-outdoor spaces, especially for those who live in mild climates or entertain often.

"It's so specific to how people like to live and feel in their homes," explains interior designer Louis Duncan-He. "I do think there is a slight shift right now to floor plans that allow a little more privacy, where you or a family member can find little moments of solitude. But the open, airy floor plan, whether for a home or loft, will always be in the conversation."

Want more gardening tips? Sign up for our free gardening newsletter for our best growing tips, troubleshooting hacks, and more!

It can be tricky to lay out furnishings: Since there aren't pre-separated areas, you have to create makeshift rooms or zones within the space. "This might involve some clever plays with area rugs, or having a bookshelf or partition installed on the back of a sofa to create a sense of division," says Duncan-He.

They can feel impersonal: Because rooms are large and open, they can lack intimacy and privacy. "While the volume of the room might technically be larger, open floor plans can feel constraining because there is no other space to escape from everyone else, and these open spaces don’t often have a cozy feeling that some people desire," LaMarque says.

Clutter is on display: This is a pro and a con—but it's certainly harder to contain clutter in open spaces. "You can’t just shut the door, quiet the noise, and hide the mess," notes LaMarque. 

Tip

There are drawbacks to closed concept floor plans, too, that certain households should keep in mind depending on your household.

"[They] spread everyone out, fostering isolation rather than gathering in the home, which can be especially concerning with kids and screens these days," LaMarque says.

The Benefits of an Closed Concept Floor Plan

Colorful home office with accent closet wall.

Credit: Twelve 15 Design Studio

Whole open floor plans offer a host of benefits—inviting people to gather together, creating an airy feel, and bringing in more natural light—there is a reason closed concept floor plans are in. Here are some of their benefits:

You can play around with design styles: Having separate spaces means that each room can feel like its own portal. "[They] provide an ample canvas for different design materials and selections," says LaMarque. "Often, homes with closed floor plans provide more opportunities for architectural details such as moldings, woodwork, and decorative hardware that provide a timeless and classic aesthetic throughout."

They blend personality and practicality: "Homes with closed-style floor plans that have more walls, rooms, and smaller spaces often feel more charming, cozy, multi-functional, and intimate," LaMarque says.

There's opportunity for specialized spaces: Designated areas don't just allow everyone to spread out independently. "Clients might want a room that functions as a den, a library, and a home gym," says LaMarque. "The additional walls, doors, and pass-throughs of closed-style floor plans offer this flexibility."

How to Make an Open Concept Floor Plan Feel Timeless

Credit: Emily Henderson Design / Photo by Sara Liggoria-Tramp

Not sold on closed concept spaces? You can still make open plan concepts work by following these guidelines:

Add architectural details: Duncan-He suggests utilizing crown molding or beams. "[This ensures] you are giving the space a sense of soul and not just relying on decor," he says.

Focus on unique wall treatments: LaMarque likes using ones that provide texture and depth, like Venetian plaster treatments or wood paneling such as shiplap or wainscoting.

Don’t forget the ceiling: The ceiling acts as an expansive fifth wall in open concept spaces. "Create architectural and visual interest [with] soffits, coffers, and cove lighting," LaMarque recommends.

Integrate time-tested materials: "Oak flooring, painted cabinetry, marble tile and stone, and decorative hardware throughout [can] soften large open spaces," LaMarque says.

Light it up: Make sure there's decorative lighting at eye level—along with feature lighting. "Recessed can lighting in the ceiling is functional and great task lighting, but floor lamps, pendants, and sconces create warmth and coziness within the space," LaMarque notes.

Article Tags:

• Home Display